Organisational culture has a significant influence on how people experience their work, how they behave and whether they choose to stay. Leadership plays a central role in shaping that culture, often through decisions that are not explicitly recognised as cultural decisions.

Research by Donald Sull, Charles Sull and Ben Zweig illustrates its importance. Analysing attrition data alongside more than 1.4 million Glassdoor reviews for large US employers, they found that toxic organisational culture was more than ten times as predictive of employee attrition as compensation during the period studied in 2021. For leadership teams that invest considerable effort in pay and benefits, the finding deserves attention. Compensation matters, but so does the everyday experience of working within an organisation when employees decide whether to stay.

The challenge is that culture is often described in terms that make it difficult to act upon. “The way things are done around here” captures something recognisable about organisational life, yet it describes an outcome rather than the conditions that produce it. Edgar Schein, whose work shaped much of our understanding of organisational culture, offered a more useful starting point. In ‘Organizational Culture and Leadership’, he describes culture as the shared assumptions a group develops as it learns which approaches to its problems work, and which are subsequently passed on to newcomers as the appropriate way to think and behave.

The practical implication is significant: if culture is learned, it is also taught, and every organisation is teaching it continuously, whether or not it intends to.

What organisations say and what employees learn

When organisations set out to strengthen their culture, they often begin with communication. Values are revisited and launched, engagement initiatives are introduced, and leadership offsites conclude with commitments to new ways of working. These efforts have value, as people need to understand what their organisation stands for and the behaviours it expects.

But communication alone cannot establish a culture, because employees also learn from what they observe happening around them. They notice who is promoted and on what basis, which projects receive investment, how performance is assessed, whose contributions are recognised and how difficult situations are handled. Each of these decisions communicates something about the organisation’s priorities.

The difficulty is that such decisions are often made by different people, at different times and under different circumstances. They are rarely examined collectively for the messages they send. As a result, the culture employees experience can gradually drift away from the values leadership has articulated, without anyone having deliberately chosen that direction.

A familiar example is how organisations handle exceptions. A business faces a short-term pressure: a high performer is considering an offer elsewhere, a senior hire expects terms outside the established reward structure, or a manager requests special treatment for someone considered critical to the business. An exception is made to resolve the immediate situation. Each decision may be reasonable in isolation and made with good intentions. Over time, however, exceptions can accumulate into a pattern that employees recognise: which rules are flexible, whose circumstances receive consideration and which behaviours are accepted when results are strong. The written values remain unchanged, while the lived culture is being shaped by decisions that were never intended to define it.

This does not mean exceptions are inherently problematic. Organisations need room for judgement, particularly when individual circumstances do not fit established rules. Consistency does not require every decision to be identical. What matters is whether exceptions are guided by clear principles, can be explained and are approached consistently in comparable circumstances. When exceptions depend primarily on seniority, influence or short-term pressure, they begin to communicate a different set of organisational values.

From cultural aspirations to organisational practices

Approaching culture as something that can be deliberately shaped changes where leadership teams direct their attention. Rather than immediately introducing new initiatives, they can begin by examining the decisions the organisation has already made. Do recent promotions, performance assessments, reward decisions and approved exceptions reflect the values the organisation wants to uphold? Looking at these decisions collectively can reveal where stated values and everyday practices are aligned, and where they may be sending different signals.

The second consideration is consistency over time. Culture cannot depend entirely on the judgement or personal approach of individual managers. Organisations need shared principles and frameworks that support decisions across teams, while allowing sufficient flexibility to respond to different circumstances. These frameworks do not eliminate judgement. They provide a consistent basis for exercising it.

When organisational practices reinforce the same expectations over time, employees begin to recognise a dependable pattern. They understand what is valued, how decisions are made and what they can reasonably expect from the organisation. That predictability matters because it allows trust to develop beyond individual relationships with particular managers. People can begin to trust the organisation’s way of operating.

Culture is not simply what an organisation intends to create. It is what people learn to expect from the decisions it makes.

share this article

follow us on