The decision-making practices that help a small organisation move quickly can become the very practices that slow it down as it grows.
As organisations evolve, they gain expertise, capabilities and perspectives that strengthen the quality of their decisions. Yet growth can also make decision-making increasingly complex. A choice that once required a single conversation may now involve several functions, multiple approvals and competing priorities. Over time, decisions take longer, accountability becomes less visible and issues are repeatedly escalated. The organisation slows down, not necessarily because people are making poor decisions, but because it is no longer sufficiently clear who has the authority to make them.

Why decision rights matter

Decision rights establish who develops a recommendation, whose input is required and who has the authority to make the final decision. They also clarify who is accountable for the outcome and who is responsible for implementation, recognising that these responsibilities may sit with different people. They are particularly important for decisions that cross functional boundaries, such as resource allocation, pricing, investment priorities or changes to operating processes. Clarifying decision rights is sometimes associated with greater centralisation and control. In practice, well-defined decision rights can achieve the opposite: they allow decisions to be made closer to where the relevant knowledge and accountability sit, without unnecessary escalation.

The difficulty is that decision rights often become blurred gradually, particularly when an organisation grows faster than its structures and governance mechanisms evolve. The informal understandings that work within a founding team may not transfer to managers who join later. Committees established to address a particular issue continue operating after their original purpose has passed. A request to be consulted gradually becomes an expectation of approval. And unwritten assumptions about whose opinion ultimately prevails begin to replace formal accountabilities. These ambiguities are particularly visible where functions intersect. Several leaders may have legitimate interests in a decision, but no one has an explicit mandate to bring the discussion to a conclusion.

Research by Bain & Company, presented by Marcia Blenko, Michael Mankins and Paul Rogers in Decide & Deliver, covered more than 1,000 companies and identified a strong relationship between decision effectiveness and organisational performance. The research also reported that, once a decision-making group reaches seven people, each additional member is associated with an approximately 10% reduction in decision effectiveness. Their work examined not only the quality and speed of decisions, but also how effectively they were implemented and the effort required to reach them. The implication for organisational design is significant: how decisions are made is not simply a matter of individual leadership style. It is also a consequence of how authority, accountability and collaboration are structured.

Building clarity into the structure

Effective decision rights require more than assigning a final decision-maker. They also require agreement on which decisions can be made independently, when consultation is necessary, where authority is delegated and how disagreements are resolved. These arrangements are most effective when embedded in the organisation’s existing structures and operating practices. Role definitions and job architecture can clarify the scope of authority and accountability associated with different positions. Leadership fora can have explicit mandates, distinguishing between matters they decide, those on which they provide input and those they delegate. Planning and governance processes can establish when significant decisions are expected, reducing the repeated negotiations that otherwise take place between meetings.

This requires partnership between business leaders and HR. Leadership teams must agree how authority should be distributed and exercised, while HR contributes the organisation design expertise needed to translate those choices into clear roles, accountabilities and sustainable ways of working. Importantly, clarity does not eliminate the need for collaboration. Many decisions require perspectives from several functions, and those perspectives can materially improve the outcome.

The objective is not to reduce consultation, but to distinguish the right to contribute from the authority to decide. When disagreement arises, a shared understanding of organisational priorities and decision criteria provides a basis for resolving competing interests. People may not always agree with the final choice, but they are more likely to understand and support it when the rationale and accountability are clear.

Clarity as the basis for adaptability

Decision rights should not become another layer of bureaucracy. They need to evolve as the organisation changes.

A decision that once required executive approval may later be delegated to a business unit or moved closer to the customer. New markets, capabilities or operating models may require different functions to participate. Changes in strategy may shift where authority should sit. A clear framework makes these adjustments easier because the organisation understands its existing responsibilities and can deliberately redistribute them, rather than allowing authority to shift through informal negotiation. Ultimately, decision-making speed is not determined only by how quickly individual leaders act. It also depends on whether the organisation has created the conditions for decisions to be made, understood and implemented without unnecessary friction.

Organisations cannot eliminate the complexity that comes with growth. But they can ensure it does not compromise their ability to make decisions and act on them.

share this article

follow us on